Pie of the Month Club
Fresh, seasonal-inspired pies each month!
Be the first to try out new Pie Y'all flavors and treat your family to some "just because" goodness. You'll receive an email at the start of each month with an announcement of the flavor! Pies are picked up from my home in Goochland on the date of your choice, but cannot be shipped.
Contact Sarah to join the club!
Memberships available:
3-month subscription: $19/month
6-month subscription: $18/month
2024 POTM Flavors:
January - Lemon Blueberry Cream
February - Valentine’s Special
March - Member’s Choice
April - Chocolate Silk
May - Blackberry Crumble
June - Mango Pineapple
July - July Special
August - Cherry
2023 POTM Flavors:
January - Snickerdoodle
February - Valentine's Special
March - Lucky Leprechaun
April - Member’s Choice
May - Samoa
June - Cherry Limeade
July - Mixed Summer Berry
August - Chocolate Peanut Butter Pretzel
Sept - S’mores
Oct - Pumpkin / Apple
Nov - Member’s Choice
2022 POTM Flavors:
January - Toffee Walnut Cookie
February - Valentine's Special
March - Orange Buttermilk
April - Member's Choice
May - Oreo Cookie
June - Orange Creamsicle
July - Member's Choice
August - Kiwi Lime
September - Apple Crumb
October - Cookie Butter Chess
November - Member's Choice
2021 POTM Flavors:
January - Chocolate Cream
February - Chocolate Covered Strawberry / Valentine's M & M
March - Banana Puddin'
April - Member's Choice
May - Chocolate Caramel
June - Cherry
July - Stars & Stripes / Peach
August - Strawberry Lemonade
September - Pecan
October - Apple Butter Pumpkin
November - Member's Choice
December - Member's Choice
2020 POTM Flavors:
January - Citrus Chess
February - Valentine's Special
March - Samoa
April - Easter Special
May - Strawberry Crumb
June - Kiwi Lime
July - Fresh Peach / Peaches & Cream
August - Chocolate Peanut Butter Pretzel
September - Caramel Apple / Apple Crumb
October - Pumpkin Cream
November - Member's Choice
December - Member's Choice
2019 POTM Flavors:
January - Oatmeal
February - Chocolate Covered Strawberry
March - Honey Lemon Chess
April - Easter Special / Member’s Choice
May - Chocolate Chip Cookie
June - Mocha Fudge
July - Peaches & Cream
August - Elvis
September - Oreo Cookie
October - Caramel Apple
November - Member's Choice
December - Member's Choice
2018 POTM Flavors:
January - Browned Butter Pear
February - Valentine's Special
March - Lemon Blueberry
April - Toffee Walnut Cookie
May - Pineapple Chess
June - Peanut Butter Chocolate Pretzel
July - Strawberry Crumb
August - Kiwi Lime
September - Chocolate Chess
October - Caramel Apple
November - Member's Choice
December - Christmas Special
2017 POTM Flavors:
January - BUTTERMILK
February - VALENTINE'S M&M and CHOCOLATE COVERED STRAWBERRY
March - CHOCOLATE OATMEAL
April - BANANA COCONUT CREAM
May - HONEY LEMON CHESS
June - OREO COOKIE
July - KEY LIME
August - ELVIS
September - MOCHA FUDGE
October - PUMPKIN CREAM
November - MEMBER’S PICK
December - CRANBERRY OAT
2016 POTM Flavors:
January - OATMEAL
February - CHOCOLATE COVERED STRAWBERRY
March - CITRUS CHESS
April - BLACK BOTTOM VANILLA CREAM
May - KENTUCKY DERBY
June - S'MORES
July - SWEET TEA
August - ORANGE CREAMSICLE
September - PEANUT BUTTER CHESS
October - APPLE CRUMB
November - MEMBER'S PICK
December - CHOCOLATE CARAMEL
2015 POTM Flavors:
August - PEACH CRUMBLE
September - CHOCOLATE TRUFFLE
October - CARAMEL APPLE
November - PUMPKIN PRALINE
December - GINGERBREAD CHEESECAKE and PEPPERMINT PATTY
Fresh, seasonal-inspired pies each month!
Be the first to try out new Pie Y'all flavors and treat your family to some "just because" goodness. You'll receive an email at the start of each month with an announcement of the flavor! Pies are picked up from my home in Goochland on the date of your choice, but cannot be shipped.
Contact Sarah to join the club!
Memberships available:
3-month subscription: $19/month
6-month subscription: $18/month
2024 POTM Flavors:
January - Lemon Blueberry Cream
February - Valentine’s Special
March - Member’s Choice
April - Chocolate Silk
May - Blackberry Crumble
June - Mango Pineapple
July - July Special
August - Cherry
2023 POTM Flavors:
January - Snickerdoodle
February - Valentine's Special
March - Lucky Leprechaun
April - Member’s Choice
May - Samoa
June - Cherry Limeade
July - Mixed Summer Berry
August - Chocolate Peanut Butter Pretzel
Sept - S’mores
Oct - Pumpkin / Apple
Nov - Member’s Choice
2022 POTM Flavors:
January - Toffee Walnut Cookie
February - Valentine's Special
March - Orange Buttermilk
April - Member's Choice
May - Oreo Cookie
June - Orange Creamsicle
July - Member's Choice
August - Kiwi Lime
September - Apple Crumb
October - Cookie Butter Chess
November - Member's Choice
2021 POTM Flavors:
January - Chocolate Cream
February - Chocolate Covered Strawberry / Valentine's M & M
March - Banana Puddin'
April - Member's Choice
May - Chocolate Caramel
June - Cherry
July - Stars & Stripes / Peach
August - Strawberry Lemonade
September - Pecan
October - Apple Butter Pumpkin
November - Member's Choice
December - Member's Choice
2020 POTM Flavors:
January - Citrus Chess
February - Valentine's Special
March - Samoa
April - Easter Special
May - Strawberry Crumb
June - Kiwi Lime
July - Fresh Peach / Peaches & Cream
August - Chocolate Peanut Butter Pretzel
September - Caramel Apple / Apple Crumb
October - Pumpkin Cream
November - Member's Choice
December - Member's Choice
2019 POTM Flavors:
January - Oatmeal
February - Chocolate Covered Strawberry
March - Honey Lemon Chess
April - Easter Special / Member’s Choice
May - Chocolate Chip Cookie
June - Mocha Fudge
July - Peaches & Cream
August - Elvis
September - Oreo Cookie
October - Caramel Apple
November - Member's Choice
December - Member's Choice
2018 POTM Flavors:
January - Browned Butter Pear
February - Valentine's Special
March - Lemon Blueberry
April - Toffee Walnut Cookie
May - Pineapple Chess
June - Peanut Butter Chocolate Pretzel
July - Strawberry Crumb
August - Kiwi Lime
September - Chocolate Chess
October - Caramel Apple
November - Member's Choice
December - Christmas Special
2017 POTM Flavors:
January - BUTTERMILK
February - VALENTINE'S M&M and CHOCOLATE COVERED STRAWBERRY
March - CHOCOLATE OATMEAL
April - BANANA COCONUT CREAM
May - HONEY LEMON CHESS
June - OREO COOKIE
July - KEY LIME
August - ELVIS
September - MOCHA FUDGE
October - PUMPKIN CREAM
November - MEMBER’S PICK
December - CRANBERRY OAT
2016 POTM Flavors:
January - OATMEAL
February - CHOCOLATE COVERED STRAWBERRY
March - CITRUS CHESS
April - BLACK BOTTOM VANILLA CREAM
May - KENTUCKY DERBY
June - S'MORES
July - SWEET TEA
August - ORANGE CREAMSICLE
September - PEANUT BUTTER CHESS
October - APPLE CRUMB
November - MEMBER'S PICK
December - CHOCOLATE CARAMEL
2015 POTM Flavors:
August - PEACH CRUMBLE
September - CHOCOLATE TRUFFLE
October - CARAMEL APPLE
November - PUMPKIN PRALINE
December - GINGERBREAD CHEESECAKE and PEPPERMINT PATTY