Current Menu
The Thanksgiving 2025 menu will be live on Nov 5, and orders will open then! For now, you can order from this menu:
WHOLE PIES
Lemon Cream
Buttery graham cracker crumb crust, tart lemon filling, and freshly-whipped cream. $20
Coconut Cream
Buttery graham cracker crumb crust, coconut custard, freshly-whipped cream, and toasted coconut flakes. $22
Chocolate Brown Sugar Pecan Pie
Sarah's signature pie! Delicious chocolate chess filling topped with toasted sugared pecans. $20
Chocolate Chess Pie
Rich, smooth, and fudgey filling. $20
Chocolate Chip Cookie Pie
Gooey cookie filling with both semi-sweet and milk chocolate chips. $20
Chocolate Caramel Pie
Oreo crumb crust, stovetop salted caramel, rich chocolate ganache. $20
Chocolate Peanut Butter
Oreo crumb crust, peanut butter cream, and a chocolate drizzle. $20
Key Lime
Buttery graham cracker crumb crust, creamy key lime filling, freshly-whipped cream, and lime zest. $20
-Pies are picked up from my home in Goochland, 10 minutes from Short Pump.
-Please order at least 3 days before your preferred pick-up date.
-For special events and orders of 5 or more pies, please order 6 or more days in advance.
-Each pie - from the crust to the filling - is made from scratch with lots of love and using simple, quality ingredients. I've listed my current seasonal menu, but I love honoring special requests. Contact me if you have something custom in mind!
-Pies are 9 1/2 inches, baked in foil tins, and placed in white bakery boxes for pretty, easy transport.
The Thanksgiving 2025 menu will be live on Nov 5, and orders will open then! For now, you can order from this menu:
WHOLE PIES
Lemon Cream
Buttery graham cracker crumb crust, tart lemon filling, and freshly-whipped cream. $20
Coconut Cream
Buttery graham cracker crumb crust, coconut custard, freshly-whipped cream, and toasted coconut flakes. $22
Chocolate Brown Sugar Pecan Pie
Sarah's signature pie! Delicious chocolate chess filling topped with toasted sugared pecans. $20
Chocolate Chess Pie
Rich, smooth, and fudgey filling. $20
Chocolate Chip Cookie Pie
Gooey cookie filling with both semi-sweet and milk chocolate chips. $20
Chocolate Caramel Pie
Oreo crumb crust, stovetop salted caramel, rich chocolate ganache. $20
Chocolate Peanut Butter
Oreo crumb crust, peanut butter cream, and a chocolate drizzle. $20
Key Lime
Buttery graham cracker crumb crust, creamy key lime filling, freshly-whipped cream, and lime zest. $20
-Pies are picked up from my home in Goochland, 10 minutes from Short Pump.
-Please order at least 3 days before your preferred pick-up date.
-For special events and orders of 5 or more pies, please order 6 or more days in advance.
-Each pie - from the crust to the filling - is made from scratch with lots of love and using simple, quality ingredients. I've listed my current seasonal menu, but I love honoring special requests. Contact me if you have something custom in mind!
-Pies are 9 1/2 inches, baked in foil tins, and placed in white bakery boxes for pretty, easy transport.