Pie Y'all - Southern Pies Made from Scratch
  • Home
  • Meet Sarah
  • Pie of the Month Club
  • Contact Sarah to Order
  • Whole Pies
May & June 2022 Menu:

Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie
Oreo crumb crust with a lip-smacking' creamy peanut butter filling, drizzled with chocolate. $20

Oreo Cookie Pie
​Dense, decadent cookie base loaded with Oreo crumbs and white chocolate chips, topped with crumbled Oreos. $20

Chocolate Brown Sugar Pecan Pie
Sarah's signature pie! Delicious chocolate chess filling topped with toasted sugared pecans. $20

Cookie Butter Pie
Texture like a blondie! Drizzled witn cookie butter. $20

Chocolate Chess Pie

Southern classic. $20

Coconut Cream Pie
Graham cracker crumb crust, coconut custard, freshly-whipped cream, and toasted coconut. $20


Lemon Cream Pie
Graham cracker crumb crust, tart lime custard, freshly-whipped cream, and lime zest. $20

Chocolate Chip Cookie Pie
​Gooey cookie filling with both semi-sweet and milk chocolate chips. $20

Pecan Pie
Pecans in a rich filling. $20

-Pies are picked up from my home in Goochland, 10 minutes from Short Pump.
-Please order at least 3 days before your preferred pick-up date.
-For special events and orders of 5 or more pies, please order 6 or more days in advance.
-Each pie - from the crust to the filling - is made from scratch with lots of love and using simple, quality ingredients. I've listed my standard menu, but I love honoring special requests. Contact me if you have something special in mind!
​-Pies are 9 1/2 inches, baked in foil tins, and placed in white bakery boxes for pretty, easy transport.


CUTIE PIES
There are two ways to order:
-Individually wrapped for easy gifting ($2.65 per wrapped cutie pie / minimum order of 4 required)
-Boxed in sets of 4 or 5 ($10.40 per box of 4 / $13 for a box of 5)
-Whether choosing wrapped or boxed, cutie pies can be mixed and matched according to your tastes!

Current cutie pie menu:
Chocolate Brown Sugar Pecan
Lemon Chess
Cookie Butter
​Pecan

Peanut Butter Chess
Peppermint Brownie
Chocolate Chip Cookie

Chocolate Chess


contact sarah to order
Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
  • Home
  • Meet Sarah
  • Pie of the Month Club
  • Contact Sarah to Order
  • Whole Pies